
Lactose Intolerance vs IBS: Why Dairy Causes Symptoms
Few foods trigger bloating, diarrhoea, and abdominal discomfort like dairy products can. Most people assume if you get these symptoms after consuming dairy, you must have lactose intolerance. However, IBS can also lead to reactions to dairy products, albeit for slightly different reasons.
IBS and lactose intolerance overlap quite a bit, whether it’s the symptoms, triggers, or struggle to diagnose the condition. But how do you tell them apart? Why does IBS react to milk and other dairy products? And what can you do about it?
Find out below, or read our guide to IBS symptoms and testing.
Lactose Intolerance vs IBS: What's the Difference?
Lactose intolerance occurs when the body doesn’t produce enough lactase, the enzyme responsible for digesting lactose. That’s the natural sugar found in milk and other dairy products. The undigested lactose passes into the colon, where bacteria ferment it, producing gas, and drawing water into the bowel, causing diarrhoea.
Common symptoms include bloating, flatulence, and diarrhoea.
IBS is slightly different. It’s a disorder of the gut-brain interaction involving altered bowel habits, abdominal pain, and increased gut sensitivity. Unlike lactose intolerance, symptoms aren’t necessarily linked to a single food or carbohydrate.
Can You Have Both IBS and Lactose Intolerance?
Yes. IBS and lactose intolerance can absolutely coexist. Having IBS can also make someone more sensitive to the effects of lactose fermentation.
Why Can Dairy Make IBS Symptoms Worse?
Lactose Fermentation and Gas Production
Lactose is a FODMAP, a specific type of carbohydrate that’s more likely to cause bloating and discomfort in people with IBS.
When lactose is poorly absorbed, it can trigger symptoms in sensitive individuals. Increased gut sensitivity in these individuals can also make normal digestive processes uncomfortable.
Why Not All Dairy Products Cause Symptoms
Dairy and lactose aren’t interchangeable. While milk itself contains lactose, the various treatments for each product can reduce lactose levels. It’s worth checking the individual lactose content rather than writing off dairy entirely. For example, hard cheeses like parmesan tend to be low in lactose.
It's also worth remembering that milk and dairy products can cause symptoms for reasons other than containing lactose. High-fat foods can aggravate IBS symptoms, regardless of how much lactose they contain.
This might help explain why switching to lactose-free dairy doesn't always solve the problem. The issue may be the quantity you're consuming, the fat content, or even something else you've eaten alongside it. It's not always as straightforward as putting the blame on lactose.
How to Tell Whether It's Lactose Intolerance or IBS
Look at Your Symptoms and Their Timing
The timing is the main thing that can help diagnose the problem. Lactose intolerance only occurs after lactose consumption, even if the timing and severity can vary.
IBS symptoms, on the other hand, can occur with a wider range of triggers, including food, stress, and changes in bowel habits.
Consider Other Dietary Triggers
How do you really know that there are other triggers? It’s difficult. If there are hours between the trigger and the symptoms, you can consume all kinds of food in that time. It might be the milk you had with breakfast or it could be something you had at lunch.
That’s why it’s worth keeping a food and symptom diary. Track meals, bowel movements, and symptoms to identify potential patterns.
How Is Lactose Intolerance Tested?
Hydrogen Breath Testing
A hydrogen breath test can help identify lactose malabsorption. You drink a solution containing lactose and provide breath samples over several hours.
The test measures hydrogen produced when undigested lactose is fermented by gut bacteria. Combined with your symptoms, the results can help determine whether lactose intolerance is contributing to your digestive problems.
Learn more about our lactose intolerance breath test.
Managing Dairy-Related Digestive Symptoms
Adjust Lactose Intake Without Unnecessary Restrictions
You don't necessarily need to eliminate dairy altogether. Reducing portion sizes or limiting particularly troublesome products may be enough.
Avoid cutting out entire food groups unnecessarily, as this could reduce your calcium intake. A dietitian can help you make suitable changes.
Consider Lactose-Free Alternatives and Lactase Supplements
Lactose-free milk and dairy alternatives are useful options. Lactase supplements can also help some people digest lactose-containing foods.
However, if symptoms persist despite these changes, lactose might not be the underlying problem.
Find Out What's Causing Your Digestive Symptoms
IBS and lactose intolerance can produce remarkably similar symptoms. This makes it difficult to distinguish them without further investigation.
At The Functional Gut Clinic, we provide specialist gastrointestinal testing to help identify potential causes of persistent digestive symptoms, including lactose malabsorption.
Explore our IBS services to learn more about how specialist testing can help you understand your symptoms and find an appropriate management approach.
Read the next article: IBS and Exercise: Can Physical Activity Ease Symptoms?